For anyone ditching the car or simply looking for a greener way to transport goods and kids, the question of how to haul cargo by bike quickly arises. During my first year and a half of car-free living, a bike trailer was my go-to solution for lugging my children and our daily necessities around town. Later, venturing deeper into the world of family biking, I invested in a cargo bike. Frequently, people ask me about my experiences with both and which I prefer. Today, I’m diving into the bike trailer versus cargo bike debate, specifically focusing on bike trailers for cargo, starting with bike trailers as they were my initial choice.
Bike Trailers for Cargo
(It’s important to note that my experience with bike trailers is based on using the Chariot Cougar 2. This is a premium, high-quality model and my recommendation for families who plan to bike more regularly than just weekend park trips. The Chariot Cougar 2 is designed for those serious about using it as a primary mode of transport. If you’re after a trailer for occasional use, a simpler model might suffice. Remember, the bike trailer kit for attaching it to your bike is usually sold separately.)
A bright yellow bike trailer being pulled by a bicycle on a paved path, showcasing its use for transporting cargo and children.
Pros of Bike Trailers for Cargo:
-
Weather Protection: Bike trailers excel in shielding precious cargo, especially children, from the elements. Many come equipped with a rain cover that can be easily deployed to keep occupants completely dry and warm. I’ve biked in sub-freezing temperatures, and with hand warmers, blankets, and the rain cover down, my kids remained warm and comfortable throughout the journey. On sunnier days, vents can be opened for airflow while still providing crucial UV protection. This weather versatility makes a Bike Trailer Cargo option a reliable choice year-round.
-
Cost-Effectiveness: Compared to dedicated cargo bikes, bike trailers are generally more budget-friendly. You can acquire a brand new bike trailer and a suitable bike to pull it for around $1,000. Opting for used equipment can significantly reduce this initial investment, making bike trailer cargo setups an accessible entry point into cargo biking.
-
Versatility Beyond Cargo Hauling: A significant advantage of many bike trailers, like the Chariot Cougar 2, is their convertibility into strollers. This 2-in-1 functionality was invaluable for us. We could bike to a nature reserve, securely lock up the bike, and then convert the trailer into a stroller for exploring trails on foot. This eliminated the need for separate strollers for walks and shopping, streamlining our gear. Furthermore, with additional kits, these trailers can transform into jogging strollers or even cross-country skiing trailers, further enhancing their utility.
-
Compact Storage: When not in use, bike trailers often collapse relatively flat. This feature is particularly beneficial for those with limited storage space. Storing a folded bike trailer in a closet or under a bed is easily manageable, a considerable advantage over the bulkier profile of cargo bikes.
Cons of Bike Trailers for Cargo:
-
Weight and Drag: While modern bike trailers like the Cougar glide smoothly and incorporate suspension, the added weight becomes noticeable, especially when hauling cargo up inclines. Even without a full cargo load, pulling a bike trailer adds resistance. When my children were younger but heavier (around 2 1/2 and nearly 5 years old, weighing about 85 pounds combined), plus daily gear, the total weight became considerable. Ascending hills became a significant physical exertion, highlighting the weight limitations of bike trailer cargo systems when carrying heavier loads.
-
Setup and Attachment Hassle: Depending on your living situation and frequency of use, the setup and attachment process for a bike trailer can become tedious. Living in a smaller apartment meant I had to collapse the trailer after each use and reassemble it for the next trip. Although each setup only took a few minutes, this daily routine became a minor annoyance. For those with garage storage, where the trailer can remain assembled and ready to go, this con would be less relevant. However, for urban dwellers or those with limited storage, the setup and breakdown can be a factor to consider with bike trailer cargo.
Cargo Bikes for Cargo
(Again, my cargo bike experience is specifically with the Xtracycle Edgerunner. I chose this model over other cargo bikes for various reasons that I can elaborate on in another article.)
Pros of Cargo Bikes for Cargo:
-
Superior Carrying Capacity: Cargo bikes are engineered to handle significantly heavier and larger loads compared to bike trailers. The Edgerunner, for instance, boasts a carrying capacity of up to 250 pounds for kids and cargo combined. This robust capacity is essential for families with growing children or for those needing to transport substantial amounts of cargo regularly. For heavy-duty hauling, cargo bikes offer a clear advantage over bike trailer cargo options.
-
Effortless Heavy Load Handling: Distributing weight is key to ease of handling, and cargo bikes excel in this area. Positioning the cargo, including children, directly above or very near the rear wheel optimizes balance. The Edgerunner’s design, with a smaller rear wheel, further lowers the center of gravity, enhancing stability and making it surprisingly easier to manage heavy loads. This design advantage translates to a more stable and less strenuous riding experience, even when fully loaded, in contrast to the pulling sensation of a bike trailer cargo setup.
-
Ample and Versatile Cargo Space: Beyond weight capacity, cargo bikes provide more versatile cargo space. Many cargo bikes, including the Edgerunner, are equipped with large saddlebags or cargo boxes that offer substantial storage volume. I can easily transport the equivalent of a car trunk full of groceries on my cargo bike. Beyond groceries, cargo bikes are capable of hauling diverse items, from larger packages to even other bikes or unwieldy items like Christmas trees, demonstrating their adaptability for various cargo needs.
-
Enhanced Interaction and Engagement: Having children positioned directly on the bike fosters easy communication and interaction during rides. Conversations, storytelling, educational games like math problems, and shared observations of the surroundings become natural parts of the biking experience. This social aspect is a significant benefit for families, turning transportation into quality time, a dimension less readily available when children are seated behind in a bike trailer cargo configuration.
-
Integrated and Streamlined Unit: As a single, solid unit, a cargo bike offers advantages in terms of maneuverability, storage footprint (when not considering vertical storage), and security. Navigating through doorways, parking, and locking up a cargo bike is often simpler than managing a bike and trailer combination. With fewer components compared to a bike and bike trailer setup (two wheels versus four), there are potentially fewer mechanical points of failure, contributing to a more straightforward and reliable cargo hauling solution.
Cons of Cargo Bikes for Cargo:
-
Higher Initial Cost: Cargo bikes typically represent a larger upfront investment compared to bike trailers and standard bikes. The specialized design, robust components, and higher carrying capacity contribute to a higher price point. While the long-term utility and potential car replacement benefits can offset the initial cost, the higher price tag is a significant factor to consider when choosing between bike trailer cargo and cargo bikes.
-
Size and Storage Considerations: While potentially having a smaller footprint than a bike and trailer combined, cargo bikes are inherently larger and longer than standard bicycles. This increased size can pose storage challenges, especially for those living in apartments or homes with limited space. Maneuvering and storing a cargo bike might require more planning and consideration than a standard bike or a foldable bike trailer.
-
Learning Curve and Handling: Riding a cargo bike, particularly when loaded, has a slightly different feel than riding a standard bicycle. The longer wheelbase and added weight distribution require an adjustment period to become comfortable with handling, especially at lower speeds or when making sharp turns. While most riders adapt quickly, the initial learning curve is a factor to be aware of when considering cargo bikes for cargo transportation, especially if you are new to cycling or carrying heavy loads by bike.
If you have any further questions, please leave a comment below! I’m always happy to discuss the nuances of bike trailers versus cargo bikes in more detail. If you have personal experiences with either setup, please share them – your insights are valuable!
