Many cyclists appreciate the generous float offered by certain mountain bike (MTB) pedals. Reflecting on a switch from Shimano MTB clipless pedals, known for their tighter feel, the increased float of pedals like Crankbrothers Eggbeaters is a notable preference for some riders. This is particularly relevant when considering road cycling shoes and pedals, where options like Speedplay are also recognized for their significant float.
One common question arises concerning pedaling efficiency with MTB pedals, especially those with a minimalist platform like Eggbeaters. Compared to road-style pedals with a broader platform, the design of some MTB pedals might seem less efficient at first glance. However, personal experience often tells a different story. Long rides, even 12-hour road bike sessions, have been completed without foot discomfort, despite using cycling shoes that aren’t the stiffest or equipped with carbon soles. This raises questions about the practical significance of a wider pedal platform.
The supposed advantage of a wider platform might be marginal in real-world cycling. The difference in width is often minimal, perhaps only a few millimeters. Furthermore, the angle of a cyclist’s foot during pedaling comes into play. As the toes naturally point downwards during the pedal stroke, any theoretical benefit of a wider platform when the foot is level could be negated.
Choosing MTB pedals can also be a practical and cost-effective decision. Opting for MTB pedals can eliminate the need to invest in both new pedals and expensive road cycling shoes. For cyclists who already have MTB shoes, or those who find wide shoe options limited, especially in certain regions, sticking with MTB pedals for road riding becomes a sensible choice. This approach is particularly appealing for riders who primarily engage in road cycling but appreciate the features and compatibility of mountain bike pedal systems.
Ultimately, the decision between different pedal types depends on individual preferences and riding styles. While road pedals might be traditionally associated with road cycling, Mountain Bike Pedals, particularly those with ample float, offer a comfortable and efficient alternative for many riders, even on long road journeys.
