Cycling has always been a beloved activity for many, offering a blend of fun, efficient commuting, and excellent exercise. However, the seated posture inherent in traditional biking can lead to issues like shortened hip flexors and discomfort in the neck, shoulders, and back. For those seeking a solution without giving up the joys of outdoor riding, elliptical bikes are emerging as a compelling alternative.
About a decade ago, the concept of an outdoor elliptical bike started gaining traction. Described as a hybrid between a bicycle and an elliptical trainer, these unique machines feature handlebars and wheels reminiscent of a bike, but instead of pedals, they incorporate the large footpads found on gym ellipticals. The most significant difference? The absence of a seat. These seatless bikes are becoming increasingly visible, even catching the attention of fitness enthusiasts and athletes like 4x Obstacle Racing World Champion and Ultrarunner Amelia Boone. It’s time to delve deeper into the world of outdoor elliptical bikes and understand their effectiveness.
Understanding Elliptical Bikes: A Unique Outdoor Fitness Machine
Outdoor elliptical bikes, often simply referred to as elliptical bikes, offer a distinctive approach to outdoor fitness. Unlike traditional bicycles, elliptical bikes position the rider in a standing position, mimicking the motion of an elliptical trainer found in gyms. This design fundamentally changes the dynamics of the workout, engaging different muscle groups and reducing impact on joints. While their unconventional appearance might initially raise eyebrows, their growing popularity signals a shift in how people perceive and engage in outdoor exercise.
The Science Behind the Effectiveness: More Than Just a Bike
But are outdoor elliptical machines truly effective? Research suggests they are. A study published in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research compared the effectiveness of elliptical trainers to traditional bikes using the Wingate test, a 30-second maximum effort test measuring power output. The study assessed energy expenditure across oxidative, phosphorolytic, and glycolytic energy systems, alongside oxygen consumption and blood lactate levels.
The findings indicated that due to the increased involvement of arms, enhanced core activation, greater utilization of leg muscles, and the upright, seatless posture, elliptical trainers led to exhaustion more rapidly than conventional bikes. This is crucial because it highlights that when seeking a cardiovascular workout that maximizes effort, engaging the arms, core, and legs is paramount. Elliptical bikes achieve precisely this, offering a more comprehensive and efficient workout compared to traditional cycling. For individuals aiming to maximize their cardiovascular exercise, elliptical bikes present a potent option.
Top 3 Reasons to Choose an Elliptical Bike Over a Traditional Bicycle
Beyond their effectiveness in maximizing workout intensity, elliptical bikes offer several compelling advantages that make them a worthy consideration for outdoor fitness enthusiasts.
1. Low Impact Exercise for Joint Health
Elliptical trainers were initially conceived to replicate the motion of running while minimizing joint stress. Anyone who has used an elliptical machine can attest to its success in this regard. The smooth, oval-shaped movement of the footpads significantly reduces impact on ankles, knees, hips, and the lower back.
A study from the University of Missouri directly compared elliptical exercise to treadmill running. The results showed that elliptical workouts mirrored treadmill workouts in nearly every aspect of cardiovascular exertion, except for one critical difference: elliptical trainers generated considerably less joint impact. For those concerned about joint health but keen on maintaining high cardiovascular fitness, elliptical bikes emerge as an excellent, joint-friendly workout alternative.
2. Enhanced Muscle Building and Toning
Research indicates that elliptical bikes are more effective at engaging certain muscle groups compared to walking. A Canadian study focusing on the differences between elliptical training and walking discovered greater muscle activation in the glutes and hips during elliptical workouts.
If building a stronger posterior or enhancing hip muscle power is a fitness goal, elliptical trainers and, by extension, elliptical bikes are effective tools. Furthermore, a study from Willamette University revealed that pedaling backward on an elliptical machine can specifically target the quadriceps while simultaneously challenging coordination. This versatility in muscle engagement makes elliptical bikes a valuable asset for lower body strength and toning.
3. Full Body Engagement: Upper Body and Core Workout
The seatless design of outdoor elliptical bikes, coupled with the incorporation of arm levers in some models, leads to substantial upper body engagement. Muscles in the arms, shoulders, and chest are actively involved in propelling and steering the bike, contributing to a more comprehensive workout. Moreover, the absence of a seat necessitates greater core muscle activation to maintain balance and stability while riding.
This integrated approach allows for efficient time utilization, enabling users to work their upper body, lower body, cardiovascular system, and core muscles simultaneously on a single elliptical bike ride. This full-body engagement makes elliptical bikes a highly efficient workout option for those seeking comprehensive fitness benefits.
Choosing the Right Elliptical Bike: Top Models to Consider
While the market for outdoor elliptical bikes is still evolving compared to traditional bicycles, the available options have expanded significantly in recent years. The variety in designs, features, and functionalities can make choosing the “best” elliptical bike a subjective process. However, several standout models deserve consideration:
- StreetStrider: The StreetStrider arguably embodies the elliptical experience most authentically with its moving arm levers, similar to gym ellipticals. Ideal for those prioritizing upper body engagement, the StreetStrider also boasts indoor stand compatibility for home workouts.
- ElliptiGO Arc 8: Often cited as the most visually appealing, the ElliptiGO Arc 8 features 8 gears, making it suitable for varied terrains, including hilly areas. Considered a more affordable option within the elliptical bike category, ElliptiGO benefits from being a long-standing brand with a proven track record and diverse model range.
- Halfbike: The Halfbike presents a uniquely compact and foldable design, resembling a tricycle-scooter hybrid. Its portability makes it well-suited for commuting and storage in limited spaces. While visually distinctive, it offers a different riding experience compared to full-sized elliptical bikes.
- Wingflyer: Marketed as an “adult scooter,” the Wingflyer prioritizes fun and a scooter-like riding style. However, it is less geared towards rough terrain and may be harder to find compared to other models.
Conclusion: Embracing the Elliptical Bike Revolution
Ultimately, the ideal elliptical bike depends on individual preferences and fitness goals. For those seeking maximum upper body engagement, the StreetStrider stands out. However, all models offer a low-impact, full-body cardiovascular workout that distinguishes them from traditional bicycles.
Whether you are a runner seeking to reduce impact while building endurance, a fitness enthusiast tired of indoor workouts, or simply someone who appreciates innovative fitness equipment and the outdoors, elliptical bikes offer a compelling alternative. Once perceived as a niche trend, outdoor elliptical bikes are proving their staying power, winning over even dedicated cycling enthusiasts. They represent a fun, effective, and joint-friendly way to enjoy outdoor fitness and break free from the limitations of traditional cycling.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Consult with a healthcare professional for personalized fitness recommendations.
References:
