Steel bike frames might seem like a relic of the past in a cycling world dominated by carbon fiber and aluminum. Yet, steel retains a devoted following, and for good reason. Ask any steel bike enthusiast why they prefer this material, and you’re likely in for an impassioned explanation about its unique qualities. Steel isn’t just a material; it’s an experience.
Even as advanced materials pushed steel off the podium in professional racing, its appeal never truly faded. Cyclists who appreciate the finer points of riding understand that steel offers more than just basic functionality. We spoke to several passionate advocates for steel bike frames to uncover why they “steel” prefer steel, dedicating their time, resources, and garage space to these classic machines.
Matthias Cada from Hamburg, Germany, a dedicated collector of 80s and mid-90s steel mountain bikes, exemplifies this devotion. His passion for Ritchey models led him to create an online gallery showcasing his collection. While his collection has expanded to include other brands, steel remains the core focus.
“It’s a fluctuating number, but around 15-20 bikes is a fair estimate,” Matthias shares about his collection. “My primary interest was initially Breezer and Ritchey – the pioneers in my view. I began restoring them about eight or nine years ago, along with other brands.”
Alt text: A curated collection of classic steel bike frames in a home setting, showcasing various vintage models.
Steel Fights Back: The Practical and Emotional Appeal
Matthias’s restoration projects spurred the creation of Steelfightsback.com. This platform allows him to share his passion and connect with fellow enthusiasts, giving lasting life to stories that might otherwise disappear in social media feeds. Like many steel aficionados, Matthias highlights durability, lightweight (relative to its strength), ease of maintenance, and the artistry of craftsmanship, particularly fillet brazing, as key advantages. These practical points are often listed as unique selling propositions, but they only scratch the surface of steel’s true charm.
“Beyond the practical aspects, it’s undeniably the riding experience. I simply prefer how steel bikes respond; they possess a certain liveliness, moving with you and reacting to your input with a subtle feedback. Each steel frame feels distinct,” Matthias explains.
Alt text: Detailed view of the exquisite fillet brazing on a steel bicycle frame, highlighting the craftsmanship involved.
The Sensations of Steel: Ride Quality and Connection
Steel bike frame enthusiasts often use evocative terms like “springy,” “lively,” and “elastic” to describe the intangible riding sensation unique to steel. While these qualities might translate to racing performance, the deeper motivation for choosing steel goes beyond mere competition.
“Choosing a steel bike, whether for a casual ride or a race, is a conscious decision,” says Natalia Gardiol from Oakland, California, USA. “It’s always been important for me to understand the origin of my bike, to appreciate the design choices, and to see the hand of a craftsperson in these objects that bring so much joy. Ultimately, bikes facilitate connections – with the world, ourselves, and others. Steel, for me, enhances and deepens these connections.”
Alt text: Natalia Gardiol confidently riding her steel bicycle outdoors, embodying the joy and connection cyclists feel.
Following a bike-totaling incident, Natalia invested her insurance settlement in a high-performance road bike. She embraced racing and, like many cyclists, found that one bike often leads to another.
“When I started road racing, everyone around me was on aluminum or perhaps carbon fiber. It felt too utilitarian for me,” she recalls. “When I ventured into off-road racing (MTB, ‘cross), I naturally sought out steel bikes. Perhaps it was a bit of rebellion, or maybe an acceptance that I wouldn’t be a champion racer, that allowed me to focus on the story behind each bike rather than just seeing them as tools for performance. And surprisingly, steel bikes can certainly deliver podium finishes too.”
Consider the Ritchey Road Logic Disc frameset for a modern, beautifully crafted steel road bike.
“Steel Only”: Durability and Timeless Appeal
Stefan Scott, a year-round commuter from north of Boston, Massachusetts, USA, clocks 100 miles weekly, navigating challenging urban conditions. Boston winters are notorious for harsh conditions, leaving roads riddled with potholes, debris, and aggressive drivers. For such conditions, a durable and responsive bike is crucial. Despite the rough roads that once led to frequent flat tires, Stefan has unwavering faith in the resilience of his steel frame over decades of commuting. Stefan’s preference for steel stems from his first bike – a single-speed cruiser modified for trail riding. His steel bike collection once peaked at 27, now a more manageable six, covering various cycling disciplines. Stefan’s loyalty to steel is rooted in its reliability, rich history, and timeless aesthetic. For him, it’s “steel only.”
Alt text: Stefan Scott confidently commuting on his sturdy steel bike through city streets, highlighting the frame’s reliability in urban environments.
The adage “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” resonates perfectly with steel bikes, both literally and figuratively.
The Original #BAAW: Steel as Art and Function
Fillet-brazed steel frames often inspire admiration akin to fine art – showcasing clean lines and meticulously crafted joints designed for purpose, not just for elite competition. Thomas Frischknecht recognized these qualities when he began racing and winning for Ritchey in the early 90s. Erik Kwant’s fascination with steel was ignited in 1995 when he witnessed Frischknecht racing on a Ritchey Plexus at a World Cup event. The Plexus captivated Kwant, leading him to acquire a frame and spend three years restoring it. Initially relegated to his shed in Overasselt, The Netherlands, his wife suggested bringing this prized possession indoors.
“She thought it was a shame to hide it in the shed and suggested displaying it in the living room so we could appreciate it more,” Erik recounts. “She knew it was my most cherished bike. I still ride it occasionally when the weather is favorable.”
Alt text: Erik Kwant’s restored Ritchey Plexus steel bike frame beautifully mounted on a wall, showcasing it as a piece of art.
Erik now displays his Plexus as art, occasionally taking it out for a ride. His other steel bike, a Swiss Cross, was chosen for its aesthetics and responsive frame. These qualities, along with steel’s sustainability as the frame material with the smallest ecological footprint, solidify Erik’s preference for steel.
Since Tom Ritchey pioneered custom-designed superlight steel tubesets to optimize performance for mountain bike frames, steel has offered artisans and engineers a material to push boundaries without the compromises inherent in other materials. Tom Ritchey’s early innovation in steel frame design revolutionized mountain biking and continues to influence frame building today. His dedication to steel is a testament to the material’s enduring potential.
Fans of steel bike frames trust in steel because, unlike many things in life, it consistently delivers. Combine steel’s affordability, versatility, unwavering durability, eco-friendliness, and breathtaking craftsmanship, and it’s clear why so many riders “steel” prefer steel.
Explore more Ritchey bikes and the passionate community around them on our Instagram page.
